Module 4 Prompt
What is this artist saying about our society? Do you agree with the message?
The artist is saying that technology, particularly cell phones, allow us to record and post our good deeds, which usually feature marginalized people. The camera angle even indicates that the person recording is higher than the person on the ground and therefore better from a societal standpoint. I agree with the message in that I think people do good for good reasons, but social media and technology have allowed our egos to drive many of our actions. We like praise, and we like validation. We like feeling “good” about what we do, but not everything needs to be a photo opportunity. Overall, I think the photo makes us question: If social media weren’t around, would you still help, or would you be a bystander?
Why do you think this man wants to document his good deed?
This man probably wants to document his deed for a few reasons: to spread awareness of the homeless epidemic and how people can help and to share about it on social media. Perhaps he thinks that by him sharing his experience, it could help influence others to do the same. Maybe he had been down on his luck before and wants to give back in the same way people gave to him. Maybe he selfishly wants praise because he never got it before. There are a multitude of possible reasons.
Do you have personal feelings about what is & is not ‘in good taste’ to post on social media?
Yes, but as with many things, my feelings change all the time about what is and what is not in good taste. For example, I used to think criticizing the education field was “in bad taste,” but now, I think part of acknowledging our flaws is healthy because it can bring about change.
As for this example, I prefer seeing random acts of kindness. I see these kinds of videos often with people helping homeless people and marginalized people, and although I recognize the good that can come from it, it seems to be a bit manipulative and taking advantage of these people while they are down. I’d rather see things like this caught on camera without it being planned or noticed by someone else. At the same time, I recognize that social media is a whirlwind, and if presented with something like this or just overall bad news, I’d rather see this potential drop of hope.
Hi Staci,
Yes! Your post was spot on!! Social media and cell phones have given us the power to have validation and praise for our good deeds. One key part that I want to add is that the validation is almost instant once we post and right at our fingertips through our phones. I know that can be addicting. Thank you for an excellent post, I enjoyed the insights you wrote about!
Natalie C.